Philadelphia Federal Reserve President Patrick Harker speaks with CNBC's Steve Liesman (not pictured) after an interview in Jackson Hole, Wyoming,...
Read More
FILE – Pipes at the landfall facilities of the ‘Nord Stream 2’ gas pipline are pictured in Lubmin, northern Germany, on Feb. 15, 2022. Russia clashed with the United States and other Western nations Tuesday, Feb. 21, 2023 over the Kremlin’s call for a U.N. investigation of last September’s sabotage of the Nord Stream 1 and 2 gas pipelines from Russia to Western Europe. (AP Photo)
WASHINGTON (AP) — It’s a major international mystery with global consequences: Who was behind the explosions that damaged the Nord Stream gas pipelines last year in the Baltic Sea?
The answer has broad implications for European energy security but could also threaten Western unity over backing Ukraine in defending itself from Russia’s invasion. Or, it might shatter Russian and Chinese attempts to fix the blame on a hypocritical West.
Yet, nearly six months after the sabotage on the Russia-to-Germany pipelines, there is no accepted explanation. And a series of unconfirmed reports variously accusing Russia, the United States and Ukraine are filling an information vacuum as investigations into the blasts continue.
A look at the pipelines and what’s known about the explosions.
WHAT ARE THE NORD STREAM PIPELINES?
The pipelines, known as Nord Stream 1 and Nord Stream 2, are majority-owned by Russia’s state-run energy giant Gazprom and used to transport natural gas from Russia to Europe under the Baltic to their termini in Germany.
Nord Stream 1 was completed and came online in 2011. Nord Stream 2 was not finished until the fall of 2021 but never became operational due to the launch of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in February, 2022.RUSSIA-UKRAINE WARShell CEO pay up 50% as soaring energy prices boosted profitCanadian Olympians push for opposition to Russians in ParisRussian forces claim progress in Bakhmut but no end in sightWhy Bakhmut has taken center stage in war in Ukraine
WHY ARE THEY CONTROVERSIAL?
Both pipelines bypass existing routes that go through Ukraine, meaning not only that Ukraine loses income from transit fees but is unable to directly use the gas they carry.
Of perhaps greater concern to the West, the pipelines were seen as a move by Russia to gain further, if not almost complete, control over Europe’s energy supplies. Many in the West fear that Russia will use energy as a political weapon against European countries as it has done in the past with former Soviet states.
Despite those concerns and over the objections of the Obama, Trump and Biden administrations, the German government under former Chancellor Angela Merkel moved ahead with the construction of the Nord Stream 2 project. The Biden administration waived sanctions against German entities involved in Nord Stream 2 after securing a pledge from Germany that it would allow backflows of gas into Ukraine and would act to shut the pipeline down should Russia try to use it to force political concessions.
After Russia’s Feb. 24, 2022, invasion of Ukraine, Germany withdrew permission for Nord Stream 2, which had not yet come online.
WHAT HAPPENED TO THE PIPELINES?
First, Gazprom halted gas flows through Nord Stream 1 on Sept. 2, 2022, citing issues related to European sanctions imposed against Russia over the war in Ukraine.
Three weeks later, both Nord Stream 1 and Nord Stream 2 were hit by explosions that rendered them inoperable and caused significant leaks of gas that was idle in the pipelines. Some have said the blasts caused the worst release of methane in history, although the full extent of the environmental damage remains unclear.
The depth of the pipeline and the complexity of using underwater explosives lent credence to the idea that only a state actor with the expertise to handle such an operation could be responsible. But no one claimed responsibility.
In the immediate aftermath of the explosions, U.S. officials suggested Russia may have been to blame while Russia accused the United States and Britain of being behind them. Investigations by European nations, including Denmark, through whose waters the pipeline travels, and Germany have yet to yield conclusive results.
WHAT THEORIES HAVE BEEN REPORTED?
After months of few developments in the probes, American investigative journalist Seymour Hersch, known for past exposes of U.S. government malfeasance, self-published a lengthy report in February alleging that President Joe Biden had ordered the sabotage, which Hersch said was carried out by the CIA with Norwegian assistance.
That report, based on a single, unidentified source, has been flatly denied by the White House, the CIA and the State Department, and no other news organization has been able to corroborate it. Russia, followed by China, however, leaped on Hersch’s reporting, saying it was grounds for a new and impartial investigation conducted by the United Nations.
On Tuesday, though, The New York Times, The Washington Post and German media published stories citing U.S. and other officials as saying there was evidence Ukraine, or at least Ukrainians, may have been responsible. The Ukrainian government has denied involvement.
Germany’s Die Zeit newspaper and German public broadcasters ARD and SWR reported that investigators believed that five men and a woman used a yacht hired by a Ukrainian-owned company in Poland to carry out the attack. German federal prosecutors confirmed that a boat was searched in January but have not confirmed the reported findings.
WHAT ARE THE CONSEQUENCES FOR THOSE FOUND RESPONSIBLE?
The implications of a determination that Ukraine was behind the explosions are not entirely clear. It’s unlikely it would result in an immediate loss of Western support for Ukraine in the war with Russia, but it might dampen enthusiasm for future assistance if it was found that Ukraine or its agents carried out such an operation in European waters.
A determination that the United States or a proxy was responsible would give Russia and China additional leverage to go after the U.S. and its allies as hypocrites in their demands for the rule of the law, sovereignty and territorial integrity to be respected.
A finding that Russia was behind the explosions would lend weight to Western claims that Moscow is in flagrant breach of international law and willing to use energy as a weapon against Europe.
There is no indication of when the European investigations will be complete — and it seems improbable, given the animosity and mistrust surrounding the Ukraine conflict, that its findings will be universally accepted.
___
Latest News:
Debt ceiling deal: What’s in, what’s out of the agreement to avert US default
Head of Russian private army Wagner says his forces are handing control of Bakhmut to Moscow
Russia signs deal to deploy tactical nuclear weapons in Belarus
Scan of Titanic reveals wreck as never seen before
Russia launches fresh missile strikes on Kyiv as explosions rock Ukrainian cities
Israeli-Palestinian fighting intensifies as Egyptian cease-fire efforts falter
How does the US debt limit standoff end? A look at the possible scenarios
Posts show Texas mall gunman researched attack for weeks
Russia’s Wagner boss threatens Bakhmut pullout in Ukraine
California police detain person in connection to stabbings
Whistleblower alleges FBI, DOJ have document revealing criminal scheme involving Biden, foreign nati...
Kremlin drone: Zelensky denies Ukraine attacked Putin or Moscow
Regular internet use may be linked to lower dementia risk in older adults, study says
Morgan Stanley to cut 3,000 jobs in second quarter
US says 20,000 Russians killed in Ukraine war since December
Biden sending 1,500 troops for Mexico border migrant surge
La Nina, which worsens hurricanes and drought, is gone
Apology letter found after US citizens killed in Mexico
China threatens US entities over downing of balloon
Great Yarmouth: Huge blast after unplanned WW2 bomb detonation
Race to find survivors as quake aid pours into Turkey, Syria
US downs suspected Chinese spy balloon off Carolina coast
House GOP votes to oust Democrat Omar from major committee
Iranian Navy Ships Dock In Brazil Despite US Concerns
Biden to highlight grant for NYC rail tunnel under Hudson
Tyre Nichols’ family to address additional police discipline
Suspect in NYC truck attack that killed 8 found guilty in terror trial
Texas silent after Guard member shoots migrant on border
Ukraine war moves ‘Doomsday Clock’ to 90 seconds to midnight
In reversal, US poised to approve Abrams tanks for Ukraine
Related Articles
Key Russia-Europe gas pipeline reopens but outlook unclear
Russia’s Gazprom tightens squeeze on gas flow to Europe
Ukraine-Russia: Germany suspends Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline
1st tanker carrying LNG from US arrives in Germany
Chinese loans spell trouble for India| Will Pakistan lease parts of PoK to pay debts
Leaders from the Baltic states call on Germany for support
Germany promises modern air defense systems to Ukraine
Germany warns on Russian gas, Poland to end oil imports
Ukraine reportedly battling Russian troops on the outskirts of Kyiv
EXPLAINER: What happens to Europe’s energy if Russia acts?
US, Germany say Russia poses ‘urgent’ challenge to stability
Russian pipeline faces big hurdles amid Ukraine tensions
U.S. Military Sends Troops to Russian Border, Officials Say They Want ‘Peace, Not War’ With Russia.
G7 threatens Russia with further sanctions over Ukraine conflict ‘if required’
Intense Minsk talks enter 12th hour
Russian FM Sergey Lavrov at the Munich Security Conference
Head of Russian private army Wagner says his forces are handing control of Bakhmut to Moscow
Russia signs deal to deploy tactical nuclear weapons in Belarus
Debt ceiling deal: What’s in, what’s out of the agreement to avert US default
WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden and House Speaker Kevin McCarthy have reached an agreement in principle on legislation to increase the...
Read More
How does the US debt limit standoff end? A look at the possible scenarios
WASHINGTON (AP) — Just how does this debt limit standoff end? Plenty of scenarios are being publicly and privately gamed...
Read More
Posts show Texas mall gunman researched attack for weeks
Jessica Himes, kneeling in front of cross, holds her daughter Harper, blue shirt, as her son Hudson, left in black...
Read More
California police detain person in connection to stabbings
Police investigate the site where a homeless woman was stabbed several times through the side of her tent near Second...
Read More
Christopher A. Wray Democrat Party Democrat Propaganda Democratic Party Department of Justice Federal Bureau of Investigation Hunter Biden Joe Biden Top News United States
Whistleblower alleges FBI, DOJ have document revealing criminal scheme involving Biden, foreign national
Document said to describe an exchange of money for policy decisions Watch the latest video at foxnews.com AG Garland stands...
Read More
Morgan Stanley to cut 3,000 jobs in second quarter
May 1 (Reuters) - Morgan Stanley (MS.N) is planning to eliminate about 3,000 jobs in the second quarter, a source told Reuters...
Read More
